On occasion, healthcare worker Lorna Grinnell-Moore is met with a sudden dial tone. Commonly, she must hear to some rather bizarre false claims and, once, she remembers being shouted at.
"You will inevitably encounter individuals like those, who refuse to listen, and it feels like a failure."
Yet, this comprises the day job for Lorna. Her role involves calling families whose children have missed out on measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccinations to persuade them to become vaccinated. Suboptimal immunization levels mean the infection has taken hold in the city, predominantly in children below the age of ten.
A Proactive Response
Lorna's been here before - she was part of a team of health service staff that made 13,000 calls in a mere 90-day period after a spike in measles reports in late 2023 impacted numerous youngsters. These discussions by themselves led close to a thousand previously hesitant families and youth to opt for vaccination.
In north London, which is in the midst of a rise in measles, officials are looking to places like Birmingham for ways to get a grip on it. Several dozen infections have been confirmed so far this year, predominantly affecting small children, some of whom have been admitted to hospital.
Leveraging Veteran Staff
During Birmingham's 2023 outbreak, some ex-healthcare workers were recalled from retirement, as occurred previously. On this occasion, however, instead of administering jabs, they were being deployed to persuade people to receive them.
The unit was assigned conducting multiple phone attempts to parents and patients under twenty-five years old to discuss what was stopping them obtaining the jab against a disease that can have grave complications - such as meningitis or sight loss and, infrequently, death.
Currently, Lorna, a vaccination program lead, and a team of nurses have been enlisted to restart the phone campaign as there is another uptick in measles.
A Delicate Communication Task
This is challenging work. It takes a certain kind of approach which involves attentive listening and seeking to appreciate the individual on the line.
"Once I get a handle on where they're coming from, I can then respond to their concerns," explains Lorna. "Occasionally they are receptive, and sometimes they say they've had enough."
"This isn't a matter of becoming the bossy matron."
If people are prepared to carry on talking, Lorna feels she can then address their concerns or anxieties about the vaccine and help diminish them.
Protocols and Support
The rule is to call only three times. Another rule avoids leaving voicemails in case they can't be understood. Colleagues who speak a number of different languages, such as French, Italian, Arabic, and Urdu, can assist in outreach when English isn't a person's first language.
Alongside the phone service, the joint incident management team also runs an public awareness drive and engages with local community groups.
Clear Outcomes
The comprehensive campaign has had a noticeable influence. Over the course of 2024, a supplementary seven thousand jabs were administered – and the total number of jabs was one-fifth more than the previous year.
Specifically, there had been lower vaccine uptake among particular demographic groups, including Roma, east European, South Asian and black ethnic groups.
Linguistic challenges were met by boosting the information available in multiple languages, including publishing QR codes linked to videos explaining about the benefits, in conjunction with conventional billboard advertising.
Local Clinics Take Action
A number of primary care clinics have also started doing their own call-and-recall work. This includes practices like Hall Green Health, which has gone further by scheduling face-to-face meetings to uncertain guardians so they can talk about their worries in person with a GP.
"I believe we have grown too relaxed about the true severity of measles," says partner Dr Sonia Ashraf.
She notes there exist several elements that lead to reluctance. The fact MMR contains pork gelatine is one thing they see, yet this can be simply addressed by offering the version of the jab that is gelatine-free.
Long-refuted data from the 1990s falsely associating MMR with autism also is frequently mentioned, while many families are anxious about the quantity of scheduled immunizations offered to children. Before turning five, they will have been offered immunization on half a dozen occasions.
"Certain guardians wonder the necessity for numerous vaccines or feel their offspring can naturally fight off these infections," adds Ashraf. "We spend time going through the evidence with them – there is a lot of misinformation out there."
Budgetary Limits and What's Next
The telephone outreach program has since been extended to additional clinics. Yet, owing to financial constraints, it is something that can only be done on a limited basis. By the following year, vaccination levels dropped back to previous benchmarks, leaving the city significantly under the 95% threshold needed for herd immunity.
Even with periodic rises in infection, there has been nowhere near the scale of cases that were seen two years ago, when reported infections topped half a thousand.
A public health lead, says the outreach approach "works very well" but "not a silver bullet" and needs to be combined with other strategies. In an ideal scenario, he notes it would be implemented more broadly but more resources are necessary.
Existing monetary allocation for the initiative is secured until the conclusion of the current fiscal period.
A National Picture
Birmingham is not the only area to use this technique. Various other regions have tried similar things.
However, improving rates countrywide has proved difficult. Right now, fewer than 85% of children have had two doses by the age of five.
"This is a genuine difficulty," says an expert. "The causes of vaccine hesitancy are complicated and diverse. One thing that often gets overlooked is practical availability. For